Mittwoch, 24. April 2024, 05:39 UTC+2
Sie sind nicht angemeldet.
Sonntag, 28. August 2005, 00:01
Peter Pan Review
Dear folks,
after more than a year of work on this (including some breaks of course
) I proudly present my Peter Pan Review (I can't directly link to it because the navigation frame would be lost if I did). If you ever wondered about the differences between Barrie's novel and Hogan's film, this is the right place to go because you won't find another more detailed comparison on the web. 
Please tell me what you think about my review and give school grades from 1 (very good) to 6 (very bad).
Thanks,
Huck
after more than a year of work on this (including some breaks of course
) I proudly present my Peter Pan Review (I can't directly link to it because the navigation frame would be lost if I did). If you ever wondered about the differences between Barrie's novel and Hogan's film, this is the right place to go because you won't find another more detailed comparison on the web. Please tell me what you think about my review and give school grades from 1 (very good) to 6 (very bad).
Thanks,
Huck
Dienstag, 30. August 2005, 14:25
I like the review very much, because in nearly every single sentence I feel your love and admiration for the movie. I think that those are the best reviews in which you can feel the personal closeness between movie and the review's author. I also learned new things about the movie, e.g. the cuts or the nice comparison of book and film.
The great gallery of the screenshots combined with the comments as well as the resources and links makes it easier for the readers with less patience, because they have something at the end of the text they can look forward to
. And it is as well a cool offer for the fans.
As I know that you have spent much work in writing this, I think that it was worth the while.
So, I voted with 6. Just kidding :PP. Indeed I voted with 1.
Regards,
Damiano
The great gallery of the screenshots combined with the comments as well as the resources and links makes it easier for the readers with less patience, because they have something at the end of the text they can look forward to
. And it is as well a cool offer for the fans. As I know that you have spent much work in writing this, I think that it was worth the while.
So, I voted with 6. Just kidding :PP. Indeed I voted with 1.
Regards,
Damiano
Mittwoch, 18. April 2007, 21:27
Zitat
Originally posted by skykid
I voted 5 because your review of Peter Pan is well written and very detailed . In general a short clip from the movie ( either the trailer or anything similar ) would make your reviews even greater .
Gee- I made another mistake - did not notice that one should vote with lower points if he liked the review - so everything I wrote above is valid, but my real vote is 2 ...
sorry for my mistake ( * hides under the table and keeps silent in shame )
Dieser Beitrag wurde bereits 1 mal editiert, zuletzt von »skykid« (18. April 2007, 21:32)